Oxygen Copper
Protecting National Water Resources: A Call to Ban Copper Sulfate for Use in America's Ponds and Lakes
Protecting National Water Resources
The purpose of this paper is to recommend a prohibition of the use of copper sulfate, a toxic and bioaccumulative chemical, in America’s waters.
Background
Copper sulfate, a naturally occurring inorganic salt, is an algaecide, herbicide, germicide, and fungicide and is commonly used to maintain the aesthetic appearance of lakes, reservoirs, and ponds. Being a trace element, its poisonous effects can be detected at levels as low as .33ppm, and its toxic potency is inversely related to the alkalinity and pH of water.[1] Copper sulfate is typically applied on a bi-weekly schedule, and what does not flow out of a water body into a receiving stream ends up binding to the underlying sediment. Here, this heavy metal accumulates indefinitely, serving as a reservoir of toxicity until the sediment is disturbed and conditions favor its release into the environment.
Because of its highly caustic nature, copper sulfate has been classified by the EPA as being in toxicity class I – highly toxic – and requires the signal words “DANGER – POISON” on its container. Having the direct potential to disrupt photosynthesis, and because of its toxicity to downstream endangered species, its use requires a permit in certain jurisdictions and applications.[2]
Copper sulfate’s toxicity and propensity for accumulation is leading to a burgeoning problem at sites located throughout the US and the world. Copper pollution is beginning to affect many coastal regions where river and storm water systems discharge; sites experiencing hazardously elevated levels of copper include: Delaware Bay, Chesapeake Bay, Naples Bay, North Miami, and Lake Pontchartrain.[3] In some cases, “[copper sulfate]…is the largest contributor to copper contamination.”[4]
As the effects of copper compounds and their persistence in coastal areas become better understood, some municipalities have included in their water resource management plans measures to reduce copper levels in stormwater discharge. The application of copper sulfate as an algaecide has also been questioned in New York City, where authorities identified it as the primary cause of excessive copper levels in the City’s wastewaters and harbor.[5] However, in some cases, the specific regulatory approaches adopted have been criticized for their inefficiency. San Francisco’s initiative to control copper contamination is estimated to have an end cost in excess of one billion dollars, primarily because of its inclusion of metallic copper, as well as all copper compounds, whatever their toxicity or fate.[6] Recent initiatives are taking a new direction, which is to improve upon water resources by targeting only volatile forms of copper, including copper sulfate.
Copper Sulfate: Detrimental to National Waters
Damaging Natural Habitats
The deleterious effects of copper sulfate on natural habitats have been widely documented. Long-term case studies have shown that, while algae is temporarily killed as intended, its decaying matter contributes heavily to dissolved oxygen depletion, fish kills, and the accelerated recycling of phosphorus which promotes algal blooms.[7] Eventually, the natural balance of the water body is upset: phytoplankton, the base of the food chain, are greatly reduced and no longer support small aquatic life; sediment-dwelling insects are killed by the accumulating poison; and plants, serving as both fish food and habitat, are killed by copper sulfate’s photosynthesis disruption. After a local pond’s ecosystem has been become debilitated, the highly water-soluble residual algaecide is flushed downstream during a rain event, becoming a hazard for downstream organisms.
Catfish, one of the Fox River’s prime game fish, are visibly stressed by concentrations as low as 1.7ppm. Enzyme activity in other fish increases due to stress at 2ppm, and the negative effects suffered were still observable after two weeks in clean water.[8] Furthermore, even at suggested application rates, the algaecide has been found to be lethal to salmonoids (e.g. salmon, trout, etc.).[9]
Animals that ingest copper sulfate by drinking from contaminated water bodies are also at risk as chronic exposures have lead to problems at levels as low as 20ppm per day—commonly leading to malfunction of the endocrine gland and testes. After consumed, copper sulfate is strongly bioaccumulated, primarily in the heart, liver, brain, kidneys, and muscles of animals.[10]
Detrimental to Water Quality
As a treatment strategy, the use of copper sulfate as an algaecide addresses only the symptoms of the water body’s degraded condition, not the causes.[11] The underlying cause of the algal blooms is the urban runoff of fertilizers, detergents, and other phosphates. The use of copper sulfate does nothing to minimize or manage these nutrients. In fact, as a germicide, it destroys the beneficial bacteria that would naturally break down nutrients and, as an herbicide, kills plant life that would absorb them.
When this water is released into receiving streams, it brings with it the burden of excess nutrients and very low dissolved oxygen. Considering that nutrient overabundance is already problematic for many U.S. rivers and streams, any effort to lessen the problem should be taken. This is especially important to downstream communities that already assume additional treatment costs to make water safe and potable for their residents.
Contributing to Pollution
Pollutants are defined as chemical constituents present at toxic levels and in bioavailable forms for a sufficient period that they adversely affect the beneficial uses of a water body. Copper and its compounds are designated as pollutants, however it is the free form of the copper II ion that is biologically available and the most toxic form of this substance. It is therefore important in creating a control approach to differentiate between sources such as metallic copper from brake pads and liners, and a wide array of ionic forms of copper of varying degrees of potential toxicity, the most problematic of which is copper sulfate. Thus, environmental scientists continue to emphasize the importance of focusing “pollutant control on those chemical constituents that are significantly impairing…waterbody(s) within and downstream of the watershed.”[12]
Residents add copper sulfate to water bodies to satisfy an aesthetic desire, often without considering its potentially harmful effects. This is especially true for storm detention ponds, which are increasingly seen as amenities and not as serving a specific, environmental function. No longer should copper sulfate be permitted at the detriment of the local and downstream environments. An opportunity to remove an unnecessary, biologically available toxin from your local water bodies presents itself without significant drawbacks—and because of this, use of the copper sulfate pollutant should be forbidden.
On the Environmental Frontier
In considering a ban on copper sulfate, your community would not be unprecedented. A number of jurisdictions are, or have, considered a ban on the use of copper sulfate. Based on data revealing that copper “hot spots” coincide with storm water discharge points in the bay, the Naples City Council will consider a resolution in November 2008 that would prohibit the use of copper sulfate as an algaecide. In early 2008, the City amended its budget, approving the installation of aerators in its stormwater retention ponds and lakes, in place of algaecide use to control algal blooms.13
Across the ocean from Naples, the European Union had scheduled a complete ban on all copper based algaecides because of the “effects of its use on the aquatic environment, impact on aquatic organisms, and soil accumulation.”[13] Reviewers found copper sulfate “not compatible with sustainable ecosystems and recommended against its use,” expressing concern about the impact it has when flushed into natural water bodies. [14] For these reasons, the review panel concluded that copper sulfate “should never be considered as a routine and convenient treatment to handle [algal] problems.”[15]
A Call to Action
As copper pollution becomes more widely recognized, more jurisdictions will move toward legislative and regulatory prohibitions targeting copper and its compounds. Your local community has the opportunity to protect its ecosystems and preserve its vital water resources by preventing the intentional application of copper sulfate, a toxin and pollutant, to its waters.
By limiting this ban to copper sulfate as an algaecide, rather than more broadly to other copper species, smaller municipalities will be able to apply limited resources in the most beneficial and cost-effective manner.
References
1. Iowa State University. Managing Iowa Fisheries: Use of Copper Compounds in Aquatic Systems.” http://www.extension.iastate.edu/Publications/PM13521.pdf
2. Extension Toxicology Network. Pesticide Information Profiles: Copper Sulfate. http://extoxnet.orst.edu/pips/coppersu.htm
3. Thomas O’Connor and Gunnar Lauenstein. “Status and trends of copper concentrations in mussels and oysters in the USA.” National Centers for Coastal Ocean Science in Marine Chemistry, no. 97 (2005) p 49-59.
4. http://www.naplesnews.com/news/2008/may/24/federal-study-naples-bay-national-hot-spot-copper-/
5. http://www.grredlee.com/wswqsour.htm
6. http://www.gfredlee.com/watershe.htm
7. Mark Hanson and Heinz Stefan. “Side effects of 58 years of copper sulfate treatment on the Fairmont Lakes, Minnesota.” Journal of the American Water Resources Association. Vol 2:6, pp 889-900. June 2007.
8. European Union Technical Advisory Panel. “Copper sulfate for use as an algicide and invertebrate pest control,” September 2001. http://www.omri.org/coppersulfate.pdf
9. ISU, Managing Iowa Fisheries
10. Extension, Pesticide Profiles
11. ISU, Managing Iowa Fisheries
12. Lee, Aquatic Chemistry
13. Personal Communication and Staats, Federal Study
14. EU, Copper Sulfate for use
15. Ibid.
16. In light of these events, we have limited our recommendation to a ban on copper sulfate specifically for water applications.
About the Author
Braden Galbreath-O'Leary is a pond management expert for Triplepoint Water Technologies, based outside of Chicago, IL. He and his colleagues are committed to providing efficient, sustainable, and environmental solutions to the water and waste wastewater industries.
For more information on the Pond Management, visit our home page and watch the video on Eco-Friendly Pond Aeration.
To read more about ponds, visit the Pond Blog.
coppersmithing class at acc jul 5, 2010 copper patina oxygen acetylene smithing .
 |
 Phoenix Gold Model M 1250 Super Oxygen Free Copper 12 Gauge Speaker Cable $25.00 Time Remaining: 23d 17h Buy It Now for only: $25.00 Buy It Now |
 9999 Oxygen Free Copper conductors with gold plating $19.59 Time Remaining: 2h 57m Buy It Now for only: $21.56 Buy It Now |
 8 GAUGE 25 FT POWER WIRE CABLE OXYGEN FREE COPPER $14.25 Time Remaining: 26d 1h 11m Buy It Now for only: $14.25 Buy It Now |
 1 FOOT 0 1 0 Gauge Ga AWG Red Tsunami OFC Oxygen Free Copper Power Wire Cable $5.97 Time Remaining: 25d 22h 48m Buy It Now for only: $5.97 Buy It Now |
 25FT 18AWG GAUGE SPEAKER WIRE CLEAR OXYGEN FREE COPPER $2.00 Time Remaining: 7d 9h 6m Buy It Now for only: $2.00 Buy It Now |
 9999 Oxygen Free Copper conductors with gold plating $16.59 Time Remaining: 2h 57m Buy It Now for only: $18.26 Buy It Now |
 18 Gauge Speaker Wire Blue Silver Oxygen Free Copper $7.00 Time Remaining: 7d 22h 26m Buy It Now for only: $7.00 Buy It Now |
 BTG Audio 10 Ft stranded 26 AWG Oxygen free copper Polyethylene clear $8.50 Time Remaining: 16d 2h 17m Buy It Now for only: $8.50 Buy It Now |
 1 FOOT 1 0 Gauge Ga AWG Black Tsunami OFC Oxygen Free Copper Power Wire Cable $5.97 Time Remaining: 25d 22h 48m Buy It Now for only: $5.97 Buy It Now |
 9999 Oxygen Free Copper conductors with gold plating $19.59 Time Remaining: 2h 58m Buy It Now for only: $21.56 Buy It Now |
 10 AWG Gauge Professional Oxygen Free Copper OFC Speaker Wire Audio Cable 100FT $84.50 Time Remaining: 11d 1h 50m Buy It Now for only: $84.50 Buy It Now |
 25FT 12AWG GAUGE SPEAKER WIRE CLEAR OXYGEN FREE COPPER $10.45 Time Remaining: 25d 6h 27m Buy It Now for only: $10.45 Buy It Now |
 Rebel Crystal Phoenix High Resolution oxygen free copper speaker cable 2 Meter $29.90 Time Remaining: 6d 9h 25m Buy It Now for only: $29.90 Buy It Now |
 100ft 14AWG Loud Oxygen Free Copper Speaker Wire Cable $9.95 Time Remaining: 2d 3h 4m |
 6 Foot Audio RCA Cord Oxygen Free Copper Wire Premium $8.31 Time Remaining: 18d 21h 50m Buy It Now for only: $8.31 Buy It Now |
 100ft 12AWG Enhanced Loud Oxygen Free Copper Speaker Wire Cable Car Home 12 2 $43.99 Time Remaining: 12d 7h 40m Buy It Now for only: $43.99 Buy It Now |
 Philips Oxygen Free Copper 50ft Roll of Speaker Wire 14 Gauge Fine Stranded $9.99 Time Remaining: 18d 19h 41m Buy It Now for only: $9.99 Buy It Now |
 8 GAUGE 25 FEET POWER WIRE CABLE OXYGEN FREE COPPER $14.25 Time Remaining: 17d 3h 31m Buy It Now for only: $14.25 Buy It Now |
 New 1m OXYGEN Free Pure Copper BELDEN Indoor Outdoor HC2 Amplifier Speaker Cable $0.90 Time Remaining: 2d 7h 2m Buy It Now for only: $1.88 Buy It Now |
 Oxygen Free OHFC Copper Rod 250 635mm Dia x 6 $6.73 Time Remaining: 26d 16h 44m Buy It Now for only: $6.73 Buy It Now |
 25 Foot Audio RCA Cord Oxygen Free Copper Wire Premium $9.99 Time Remaining: 26d 22h 21m Buy It Now for only: $9.99 Buy It Now |
 30FT 14GA Oxygen Free Hi Current Parallel Speaker Cable w Copper Banana Plugs $19.25 Time Remaining: 24d 21h 18m Buy It Now for only: $19.25 Buy It Now |
 12AWG Enhanced Loud Oxygen Free Copper Speaker Wire Cab $4.95 Time Remaining: 2d 3h 3m |
 COPPER PURE 9999 OXYGEN FREE ANODES CASTING ALLOY $12.50 Time Remaining: 11d 22h 24m Buy It Now for only: $12.50 Buy It Now |
 16GA Oxygen Free Hi Current Parallel Speaker Cable w Copper Banana Plugs 30ft $14.75 Time Remaining: 25d 1h 32m Buy It Now for only: $14.75 Buy It Now |
 8 GAUGE 10 FEET POWER WIRE CABLE OXYGEN FREE COPPER $7.90 Time Remaining: 24d 3h 5m Buy It Now for only: $7.90 Buy It Now |
 100ft 12AWG Loud Oxygen Free Copper Speaker Wire Cable $14.50 Time Remaining: 2d 3h 3m |
 50ft 14AWG Enhanced Loud Oxygen Free Copper Speaker Wire Cable Car Home 14 2 $24.49 Time Remaining: 12d 7h 50m Buy It Now for only: $24.49 Buy It Now |
 Hitron SPW18 50 50 ft of 18 Gauge Oxygen Free Copper OFC Speaker Wire $6.99 Time Remaining: 22d 4h 28m Buy It Now for only: $6.99 Buy It Now |
 Audiophile Grade 50ft 14AWG Oxygen Free Copper OFC Loud Speaker Wire Cable $22.95 Time Remaining: 23d 18h 28m Buy It Now for only: $22.95 Buy It Now |
 100ft 16AWG Loud Oxygen Free Copper Speaker Wire Cable $7.50 Time Remaining: 2d 3h 4m |
 25 Foot Audio RCA Cord Oxygen Free Copper Wire Premium $17.09 Time Remaining: 17d 22h 49m Buy It Now for only: $17.09 Buy It Now |
 Oxygen Free OHFC Copper Tube 500 OD x 032 x 6 $7.99 Time Remaining: 14d 6h 9m Buy It Now for only: $7.99 Buy It Now |
 Oxygen Free OHFC Copper Rod 125 318mm Dia x 6 $3.72 Time Remaining: 9d 4h 25m Buy It Now for only: $3.72 Buy It Now |
 Hosa GTR 210 10 ft Guitar Instrument Cable with Oxygen Free Copper Conductors $9.99 Time Remaining: 1d 11h 28m Buy It Now for only: $9.99 Buy It Now |
 lot 39 pieces of 9 Foot Audio RCA Cord Oxygen Free Copper Wire Premium $49.99 Time Remaining: 4d 1h 11m |
 Honeywell Genesis 54741001 16 4 Oxygen Free Copper Cable White 1000 $380.69 Time Remaining: 18d 3h 12m Buy It Now for only: $380.69 Buy It Now |
 Oxygen Free OHFC Copper Tube 375 OD x 032 x 6 $6.96 Time Remaining: 14d 6h 9m Buy It Now for only: $6.96 Buy It Now |
 Oxygen Free OHFC Copper Rod 156 397mm Dia x 6 $6.78 Time Remaining: 9d 4h 40m Buy It Now for only: $6.78 Buy It Now |
 37 lot of 12 Foot Audio RCA Cord Oxygen Free Copper Wire Premium $49.99 Time Remaining: 4d 20h 57m |
 2m USB 30 Extension Cable 2 Meter SuperSpeed 5Gbps Quality Oxygen Free Copper $9.46 Time Remaining: 28d 13h 15m Buy It Now for only: $9.46 Buy It Now |
 Rockford Fosgate RFK4D 4 8 Gauge Dual Amplifier Install Kit Oxygen Free Copper $84.95 Time Remaining: 15d 16h 41m Buy It Now for only: $84.95 Buy It Now |
 Kicker 09PKD1 Dual 1 0 Gauge Car Amplifier Wiring Kit With Oxygen Free Copper $189.95 Time Remaining: 18d 23h 6m Buy It Now for only: $189.95 Buy It Now |
 lot of 6 15 Foot and 2 20 foot Audio RCA Cord Oxygen Free Copper Wire Premium $27.99 Time Remaining: 5d 20h 10m |
 100ft 14AWG Enhanced Loud Oxygen Free Copper Speaker Wire Cable Car Home 14 2 $39.99 Time Remaining: 12d 7h 51m Buy It Now for only: $39.99 Buy It Now |
 50 ft 14AWG Enhanced Loud Oxygen Free Copper Speaker Wire Cable Car Home 14 2 $23.88 Time Remaining: 12d 8h 29m Buy It Now for only: $23.88 Buy It Now |
 Oxygen Free OHFC Copper Rod 375 953mm Dia x 6 $9.12 Time Remaining: 14d 6h 16m Buy It Now for only: $9.12 Buy It Now |
 12 AWG speaker wire 100 ft Enhanced Loud Oxygen Free Copper Speaker Wire Cable $9.99 Time Remaining: 1d 22h 17m Buy It Now for only: $39.99 Buy It Now |
 30FT 16GA Oxygen Free Hi Current Parallel Speaker Cable w Copper Banana Plugs $14.76 Time Remaining: 24d 22h 18m Buy It Now for only: $14.76 Buy It Now |
 Honeywell Genesis 54756101 14 2 Oxygen Free Copper Cable White 500 $165.07 Time Remaining: 13d 8h 12m Buy It Now for only: $165.07 Buy It Now |
 KW PROLINK 25PIN M F COMPUTER CABLE 18m 3m OFC Oxygen Free Copper cable $24.77 Time Remaining: 13d 12h 8m Buy It Now for only: $24.77 Buy It Now |
 Premium 14/2 Awg 100ft CL2 Speaker Wire | Cable - Oxygen Free Copper List Price: Sale Price: $25.89 You save: $19.31 (43%)  Eligible for free shipping!Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days See Reviews For This Product DescriptionOxygen free In Wall speaker wire, capable of producing the cleanest sound possible. Flexible No-Kink Jacket provides easy professional results for the DIY'er or Professional alike  |
 DURAGADGET 3.5mm Gold plated, OFC (Oxygen free copper) cable Stereo clip on Stereo Headphones for HP Pavilion dm3-1060ea 13.3", Mesh Discovery Slim 13.4" List Price: Sale Price: $13.18 You save: $16.55 (56%) Eligible for free shipping!Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days See Reviews For This Product DescriptionTechnical data: Frequency range: 20 - 20.000 HzImpedance: 32 ohmsSensitivity: 102 dBPlug: jack, 3.5 mm, stereo, gold-platedCable length: 1.1 m, OFC cable Colour: black |
 Brand New Monster Cable Xln16s-20 16 Gauge 20' Foot Oxygen Free Copper Speaker Wire Spool Sale Price: $9.99 Eligible for free shipping!Availability: Usually ships in 24 hours See Reviews For This Product DescriptionBRAND NEW MONSTER CABLE XLN16S-20 16 GAUGE 20' FOOT OXYGEN FREE COPPER SPEAKER WIRE SPOOL Advantages of the XLN16S-20: 16 gauge SingleHelix construction eliminates loop area noise and inductive interference... |
 A Strange Manuscript Found in a Copper Cylinder List Price: See Reviews For This Product DescriptionIt occurred as far back as February 15, 1850. It happened on that day that the yacht Falcon lay becalmed upon the ocean between the Canaries and the Madeira Islands. |
 New CABLES TO GO 12ft Velocity Component + Audio Cable 75-Ohm Oxygen-Free Copper Center Conductor List Price: Sale Price: $49.99 You save: $12.39 (20%) Eligible for free shipping!Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days See Reviews For This Product DescriptionNotice: $50 charge per refused shipment unless the refusal is based on our error. Customers should thoroughly inspect all cartons for damage before signing for the shipment.Damage: Must be reported within 15 days from delivery date... |
 Copper C101 Round Rod, Oxygen-Free, ASTM-B187, 3/8" OD, 72" Length List Price: Sale Price: $55.22 You save: $4.22 (7%) Eligible for free shipping!Availability: Usually ships in 24 hours See Reviews For This Product DescriptionCopper Rod Type C101- ASTM B187-C Oxygen-Free, High Conductivity Copper is produced by direct conversion of selected refined cathodes and casting under carefully controlled conditions to prevent any contamination of the pure oxygen-free metal during processing... |
 NEW Gold HD Component Cable 480p for Nintendo Wii HDTV List Price: Sale Price: $4.37 You save: $22.62 (84%) Eligible for free shipping!Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days See Reviews For This Product DescriptionOur cables perform same or better to those branded cables with much affordable price !! This cable is a must to get the best possible pictures on Wii. If you want to use HDTV or EDTV setting, you need to use high quality component AV cables like this... |
 Oxygen Acetylene Brazing (DVD 68 minutes) Sale Price: $39.95 See Reviews For This Product Description"If you are a beginner or you haven't brazed in awhile and want to build and repair using the oxygen acetylene torch, then this video is specifically for you. We'll start off with torch selection. Your choice of torch is directly related to the type of work that you plan on doing... |
 Hobart 770514 Mild Steel Copper-Coated Oxy-Acetylene Welding Rod, 3/32-by-18-Inch Sale Price: $16.92 Eligible for free shipping!Availability: Usually ships in 24 hours See Reviews For This Product |
![AmazonBasics High-Speed HDMI Cable (6.5 Feet/2.0 Meters)[Supports 3D + Audio Return Channel][OLD MODEL]](http://www.verticalmusictv.com/media/images/i/41HvrDRBhDL._SL75_.jpg)
![AmazonBasics High-Speed HDMI Cable (9.8 Feet/3.0 Meters) [Supports 3D + Audio Return Channel]](http://www.verticalmusictv.com/media/images/i/41nAsytjSsL._SL75_.jpg)
![AmazonBasics High Speed HDMI Cable (6.5 Feet / 2.0 Meters) - Supports Ethernet, 3D, and Audio Return [NEW MODEL]](http://www.verticalmusictv.com/media/images/i/417qWBWXqYL._SL75_.jpg)